How to Compare Two Job Offers: Total Comp Guide

Why Base Salary Comparisons Are Almost Always Wrong

The average professional compares job offers by looking at two numbers: the base salary and maybe a vague sense of 'the benefits seem good.' This approach systematically undervalues certain components — usually benefits and equity — and systematically overvalues others — usually signing bonuses without accounting for clawback risk.

In a typical professional role, non-salary components add 20–50% to the value of a compensation package. A $150,000 base with 15% target bonus, $20,000 in RSUs, a 4% 401k match, and employer-covered health insurance is worth approximately $205,000 in total annual compensation. An offer with $165,000 base but no equity, no 401k match, and employee-paid health insurance might only total $172,000. The lower-base offer is worth $33,000 more per year — a difference that compounds significantly over a 3–5 year tenure.

The framework below walks through every major compensation component, how to calculate its annual dollar value, and how to account for risk in components like equity and variable bonus.

Run the comparison in 3 minutes

Enter both offers and see a complete side-by-side breakdown including equity scenarios, benefits valuation, and a winner determination.

Compare My Offers

How to Calculate Total Compensation — Component by Component

1
Base Salary
The foundation. Annual base salary, paid regardless of performance. Use the pre-tax number for comparisons — taxes affect both offers equally. Note whether salaries are reviewed annually (most companies) or only at promotion. A higher-base offer with infrequent review may fall behind a lower-base offer with aggressive annual adjustments.
2
Annual Bonus
Use target bonus, not maximum. If the offer says '15% target bonus,' that means 15% of base salary at expected performance. In practice, many companies pay 80–120% of target depending on company and individual performance. Express as annual dollar value: $150,000 base × 15% = $22,500 target. Be skeptical of companies where max bonus is achievable only in exceptional years.
3
Equity / RSUs / Options
For RSUs: divide the total grant value by the vesting period (typically 4 years) to get annual value. For public company RSUs, use current stock price — but note the stock can appreciate or decline. For startup equity, model three scenarios: 0x (worthless), 3x (modest exit), and 10x (strong exit). Weight by your probability assessment. Stock options require knowing the strike price and current 409A valuation to determine in-the-money value.
4
401(k) Match
Calculate as: salary × match percentage, capped at the employer's matching limit. A '4% match' on $140,000 = $5,600/year. Some employers match on compensation up to the IRS limit; others cap matching at a lower salary. Also note vesting schedules — immediate vesting vs. 3-year cliff vesting affects the real value if your expected tenure is short.
5
Health Insurance
Calculate as: (monthly premium) × 12 × (employer contribution percentage). If the full monthly premium is $600 and the employer covers 80%, they're contributing $5,760/year. For family coverage, premiums can be $1,500–$2,000/month — employer contribution differences of 20–30% can represent $3,600–$7,200/year. Also compare plan quality: deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, and network breadth vary significantly.
6
PTO and Holidays
Value PTO above a baseline as: (salary ÷ 260 working days) × extra days. If Offer A gives 25 days PTO and Offer B gives 15 days PTO, and your salary is $140,000, the 10-day difference is worth $5,385. Also count company holidays separately — some employers offer 8–10 paid holidays; others offer 13–15. Total days off is the metric that matters.
7
Signing Bonus
Annualize over your expected tenure. A $20,000 signing bonus over a 2-year stay = $10,000/year. Check the clawback clause: if you must repay the bonus if you leave within 12 months, you're effectively accepting lower-than-advertised pay for the first year. Factor in any income tax implications — signing bonuses are taxed as ordinary income in the year received.

The Equity Scenario Framework

Equity is the component most likely to swing a total compensation comparison. The right way to evaluate it depends heavily on whether you're comparing public company RSUs, late-stage startup RSUs, or early-stage options.

Public company RSUs are the most straightforward: the stock price today is your reference point. The risk is stock price movement — in both directions. A $200,000 RSU grant at a company whose stock has historically been volatile should be valued more conservatively than the same grant at a stable blue-chip. Model a bear case (stock down 30%) and a base case (flat) and a bull case (up 50%) to bracket the outcome.

Private company equity is more complex. The critical question is: what is the current 409A valuation, and what is the last preferred share price from the most recent funding round? Options are typically struck at 409A price, which is often significantly below the preferred round price. A $4 strike on stock trading at $8 preferred has $4 of in-the-money value — but only if the company actually exits and you're not underwater in the preference stack. The realistic value for early-stage equity is often between 0 and 30% of what the face value suggests.

For any offer with meaningful startup equity, ask directly: What is the current 409A valuation? What is the last round price? What is the preference stack? How many fully diluted shares are outstanding, and what is my grant as a percentage of the company? These questions are standard and any legitimate company will answer them.

FAQ

How do I handle offers where some components are unknown?

Use the calculator with conservative assumptions. If the bonus is stated as a range (5–15%), use 8% as your estimate. If health insurance details aren't provided, use your current out-of-pocket cost as a baseline. If equity details are vague, use $0 in your base case and treat any positive equity outcome as upside. Conservative inputs prevent you from making a decision based on optimistic projections.

What non-financial factors should influence my decision?

Growth trajectory, manager quality, team health, and company direction often matter more than the current comp gap. A $15,000 annual comp advantage at a company with slow promotion velocity and a manager who doesn't advocate for you may be worth less than a $5,000 lower comp with a manager who makes your career trajectory steeper. The comp comparison tells you the financial difference — weigh it against these qualitative factors deliberately.

Should I tell each company about the other's offer?

This is a negotiation tactic that works best when offers are at competing companies in the same space. Sharing an offer forces the employer to explicitly decide whether to match, counter, or let you walk. Do this only if you'd genuinely accept the competing offer — never fabricate or exaggerate. The most powerful version: 'I have a competing offer at $X total comp. I prefer this role and would accept at $Y.' Be specific and have the math ready.

When should I negotiate vs. simply accept?

Always negotiate. The first offer is almost always below the employer's approved ceiling. Negotiating respectfully is expected and professional. The window is shortest after verbal acceptance — negotiate before that point. Data shows that fewer than 40% of candidates negotiate, but of those who do, more than 85% receive some increase. The asymmetric risk (small downside, meaningful upside) always favors negotiating.

Compare your specific offers now

Enter both packages and get a full breakdown including equity scenarios, a component-by-component table, and a clear winner determination.

Compare My Job Offers